Green Tomato Relish for Sandwich Spread

Green Tomato Relish

Note the misspellings, tomatoe and sanwich

Green Tomato Relish Back

Here’s how you mix it

I haven’t tried green tomatoes in any form, mostly because I don’t like tomatoes to start with. Weirdly, I like catsup, salsa, spaghetti sauce, etc., just not fresh, raw tomatoes. This is also another recipe using mangoes. I wonder if the lady who wrote these had a mango tree.

Green Tomato Relish for Sandwich Spread

Tartar sauce

24 green tomatoes (grind & squeeze juice off)

Grind together:

12 green mangoes (probably peppers)

12 red mangoes (probably peppers)

4 large onions

Cover with boiling water. Let stand 2 min. Drain through sieve.


1 c water

1 c vinegar

3 c sugar

1 med jar of French’s mustard

Salt (to taste)

Mix and cool 15 min. Take 1 c water to 1/2 c flour. Pour into mango mixture 1 qt Hellman’s mayonnaise. Mix all ingredients together, pour into pint jars & seal.

3 thoughts on “Green Tomato Relish for Sandwich Spread

    • I have been making a very similar recipe for years (16pts this summer). I place it in the mats while hot, put the lids on and it seals. Never any problems. After grinding, I salt to taste and let stand over night. Drain it very dry. Cook with vinegar, wate, brown sugar till till dry. Add mayo and mustard, put into jars. I don’t add flour


  1. This sounds very similar to the one I sent you, you sh have it in a few days. Mine a little different no flour, don’t remember Mom ever putting flour in hers? Hoping between the recipe I sent and this one you can figure it out, So happy you are going to make it, I loved it when I got it in my sandwiches at school. hugs


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.